March 24th, 2011

Judging Bobby Flay’s Key Lime Pie Throwdown

bobby-flay-300x116It was a real surprise when I was contacted to be on a Food Network “special profiling a chef in the Keys” last year. I’m not even sure how they came across my blog. All I know is that soon after, on a Monday in December, I was on my way to Marathon to tape the show.

I was told I would be tasting said chef’s food and talking about it. I wasn’t. When I arrived at Tranquility Bay Resort a guy asked me if I was a member of the audience and I quickly realized that this was a contest of some sort. I had no clue until I met the producer that I would be a judge — on a Bobby Flay show no less.

In Throwdown with Bobby Flay, Flay challenges someone who has mastered a dish or type of cooking to an unexpected throwdown. In this case, Flay surprised Jim Brush and Alison Sloat of the Key West Key Lime Pie Company, who thought their business was being profiled on the Food Network.

I was nervous the whole day. Those who know me know that I shy away from the limelight but I felt a little better when I learned that I would be judging with Miami Herald columnist and NPR radio host, Linda Gassenheimer. I wouldn’t be in it alone. We waited for some time while the cooking portion of the show was taped before going in and tasting the pies. The filming went by in a flash and after doing some rather uncomfortable “hero shots” I was on my way back to Miami.

We didn’t know who made which pie when we were tasting them, so no, we didn’t favor Flay as some of my friends have suggested half jokingly. His pie won me over; it was creamy and tart. The addition of pineapple in Jim and Alison’s pie was interesting and tasty but it downplayed the Key Lime. That’s not to say theirs wasn’t good. As for me, I had fun and I’m glad I just did it.

If you missed the episode last night, you can catch it again on April 9 at 7:30 p.m. on the Food Network.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

16 Responses to “Judging Bobby Flay’s Key Lime Pie Throwdown”

  1. You were great! Really enjoyed the show and came over here and signed up for your blog after I saw the episode.

    Would you say that Bobby’s Key Lime Pie was richer due to the egg yolks? I usually prefer a baked key lime pie to a fridge key lime pie!

  2. I watched it last night on commercials from the main show I was watching…but didn’t see the judging. I will definitely catch replay.

    What fun for you!

  3. My husband and I sw the episode last night and when they introduced you, I told him, “Hey! She’s the blogger from one of my favorite blogs!”
    It was great to see a local Blog Celebrity (that means YOU!) spotlighted on a Florida Throwdown Show! How exciting! Congrats to you!

    After watching the show, I told my husband, “guess what we’re making this Sunday ?” Key Lime Pie of course! :)

  4. Congratulations!!! What an accomplishment. I missed it last night, but I will definitely watch the rerun on April 7th!!!!

  5. Nice surprise Paula you got picked as a judge! I love Flay’s throwdowns, it’s one of my favs. The look of surprise when the contestant sees Flay is PRICELESS, ha, ha, good laugh. Have to catch it next time.

  6. Paulita you KILLED it! So articulate with your pie critiques and with a very professional stage presence. Can’t wait to hear and see who calls next :)


  7. I’m so proud of you … blog celebrity!


  8. How fun!!! I missed it last night so April 9th is in my calendar! Can’t wait to see it. xo

  9. I enjoy Bobby’s show and loved seeing you on it. You were so professional. Several of my friends watched it last night and all had positive comments. Hope to see you on another show soon! I am so proud of you!

  10. You were awesome! Our local celebrity blogger! Congrats Pau! :)

  11. Thanks for the love everyone.

    @ranger99 – Thanks for stopping by. The egg yolks probably had something to do with it. I don’t prefer the frozen pies either.

  12. You were the ‘element of surprise’. Good Stuff! You are a natural :)

  13. Paula, you did great!

  14. The reason they had you on there (and how they found you) is the fact that since 2006 you’ve put out the best content on Miami food and ethnic eats, hands down. :)

    I’ll be tuning in on April 9th to check out the re-run. Good stuff Paula!

  15. This is my first time visiting your blog – heard your URL on Throwdown and wondered over!

    Congratulations – what a huge get for a blogger to be featured on a Bobby Flay show!!!!!!!!!!! :)

  16. @Toronto Girl West – Thanks for stopping by. Beautiful pics on your blog.

Leave a Reply